How to Prepare for the Unexpected.
We’re here to help! Find out what to do, how to spot scams and which steps you can take now in case of a banking disruption or outage. Learn more >

Bankrate 5-Star Rated logo

Gate City Bank Earns 5-Star Lender Rating from Bankrate.

Gate City Bank has earned a 5-star mortgage lender rating from Bankrate Star Ratings, a first-of-its-kind, data-driven evaluation of the mortgage lending industry that reviewed nearly 2,000 lenders and analyzed 23.5 million mortgages originated between 2022 and 2025.

Rating Reflects Strength in Mortgage Pricing, Customer Experience and Lending Reach.

The Bankrate recognition places Gate City Bank among an elite group of lenders nationwide, with only 8.6% (169 of the 1,962 mortgage lenders evaluated) receiving its highest 5-star rating.

Created to help consumers compare mortgage lenders and identify those offering the best overall value, Bankrate Star Ratings assess lenders using public home lending records, customer complaint data and pricing information. The ratings are designed to bring greater transparency to the mortgage process and help borrowers make more informed decisions when choosing a lender.

“At Gate City Bank, we’re committed to helping customers achieve their homeownership goals with competitive mortgages, trusted guidance and exceptional service,” said Kim Settel, EVP, Chief Retail Banking Officer. “We’re honored to earn Bankrate’s highest rating and be recognized among a select group of lenders nationwide.”

Bankrate’s ratings are based on measurable results from a lender’s mortgage activity and are calculated using four weighted categories, with pricing-related factors making up 80% of a lender’s overall score:

  • Price competitiveness (40%)
  • Amount of overpayment compared with the best available pricing for a comparable loan (40%)
  • Customer complaints (10%)
  • Lending footprint and loan offerings (10%)

Lenders that earn five stars consistently offer some of the lowest-cost loans relative to comparable options and typically have no mortgage origination complaints on record with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Bankrate states.

These ratings are part of Bankrate’s larger push to help people avoid overpaying for their mortgages. Bankrate, a consumer advocate for home lending information, says their research found that 87% of Americans pay more than they need to on their home loans, adding up to billions of dollars in unnecessary costs each year for households that took out mortgages since 2022. With independent, data-driven lender ratings, Bankrate wants to make it easier for borrowers to find lenders that offer strong value and competitive pricing.

“We know buying a home is one of the most important financial decisions people make,” Settel said. “Receiving this recognition reflects our dedication to helping customers navigate the mortgage process with confidence.”

Want to see how other banks ranked? Check out the new Bankrate Star Ratings.

Ready to make your move? Whether you’re buying, building or refinancing, find simple answers, local servicing and trusted expertise with the #1 mortgage lender. Learn about our home loans and mortgage programs.

Our trusted lenders will guide you every step of the way. Now that’s home loans done right. Let’s get you moving!
Get Pre-Approved
Couple smiling at each other in the kitchen of their new home, thanks to help from a Fargo mortgage lender at Gate City Bank

More [Good News] Where That Came From!

sorting blue food pantry bags in West Fargo, ND

About Us

At Gate City Bank, we have a wonderful story to tell. It's aligned with our core purpose, focusing on investing in our customers, communities and team members. Learn more about us!

Joyful Gate City Bank team members volunteer for a local food pantry b sorting donated items

Our People

At Gate City Bank, our customers, communities and team members inspire everything that we are – they’re our people. Learn more about them through heartwarming stories and testimonials!

happy group cuts ribbon with scissors for West Fargo Eats ceremony

Philanthropic Giving

At Gate City Bank, giving back to the communities where we live and work is at the core of who we are. Learn about all the innovative ways we’re making a difference throughout North Dakota and central Minnesota.